
First, let me start off by saying I really love Macs. I've been using them since the Ottawa Citizen newsroom acquired a Mac Plus in 1985 with fresh copies of MacDraw, MacPaint and Cricket Draw, as well as an Apple PostScript laser printer. Yeah, I'm THAT old, so stop reminding me.
There are a number of reasons why I prefer Macs, including ease of use, everything just works, elegance, simplicity and a variety of subjective things too long to bore you with. Microsoft's Windows have always been so highly derivative of whatever Apple does that I find myself disgusted whenever I have to sit in front of a Windows screen, but I'm going on a bit of a bunny trail here.
The one thing that really bothers me about Macs is that they are, without a doubt, grossly overpriced. Yes, I've read the comparative studies of PC all-in-ones versus the iMac and I've read all the Mac fanboy reviews (trust me, I'm probably geekier than you), but the problem is once you're invested in the Mac platform (i.e. software), you don't have many options. If you are using a Mac professionally as a graphic artist, you either have to spring for the $2,800 CDN Mac Pro, or opt for one of the higher end iMacs.
The problem with the iMac line is that they are truly closed systems, similar to glorified 24" laptops. You can't just rip out the innards, such as the hard drive, or graphics card, like you can a PC. This leaves you with having to consider a forced purchase when your deliberately (by Apple) undersized hard drive on a two-and-a-half-year-old iMac gets filled, as in my case recently. This scheme works great for Apple and its shareholders, but not so good for the lowly media producer.
By far, the best computers I ever owned were the 1998 Mac G3 and a generic PC I bought in 2002 when I switched to Windows. The reason for this was simple: They were both highly upgradable and I could squeeze out an extra couple of years of service by adding an internal hard drive, replacing the graphics card and whatever else my little heart desired. This is why in many respects, PC proponents have a point when they say open systems are better. I couldn't agree more with them on that.
The other issue is that while Dell is offering the new i7 Core in their XPS desktop, starting at $999 CDN, to get equivalent performance in a Mac, I'd have to shell out $2,800 for a Mac Pro. The E8000 series chips in the high end $2,500 iMacs aren't even half as fast. The irony is that a pimple-faced kid, or grandma could buy one of those Dell i7 bad boys just to surf the Internet, while a media professional stuck in Apple's system (like me) has to pay three times the price for the Mac Pro, or be happy with paying twice as much for an iMac that delivers about 40 per cent of the processing power. The other injustice is that many people who run Macs, particularly graphic artists, are stretched to pay $2,000 for a machine that is better afforded by white collar professionals who would, ironically, probably buy the $1,000 Dell.
This scheme worked well for Apple in the happy days of the economy, but it's unconscionable in these times where people are losing their livelihoods at an alarming rate. Apple deliberately removed mid-sized towers in the late '90s as a way of forcing users to all-in-ones. Besides being extremely wasteful, as users have to buy the enclosed monitor with the machine, it is a deliberate money grab.
There are options, of course. Buy a PC would be the first obvious choice, but some of us can't stand the "me-too" derivative nature of Windows; the exposure to viruses, worms, constant security pop-ups, adware, subscriptions to virus checking software that is often worse than a virus, as well as just the plain ugliness of the Windows OS. Vista was supposed to be Microsoft's answer to OS X and it was a good attempt. Windows 7 promises to be better.
The other option is build your own Hackintosh. Trust me, I considered it. Apple doesn't like when people break the OS X EULA agreement that specifically states not to install OS X on anything but a Macintosh, but the benefits are compelling and the Hackintosh community is growing. One product I've looked at is a USB dongle called EFI-X, which seems to be a good solution for tricking a generic PC into thinking it's a Mac. For less than $1,200, you can build your own Mac with OS X that will keep up with the Mac Pro and embarrass the iMac. For a few dollars more, you can buy a ready-build Hackintosh from Psystar. Just remember that Apple is currently engaged in an epic lawsuit over Psystars right to sell PCs with OS X installed.
Frankly, I hope Psystar wins. I never thought I'd say that, but Apple needs a good reality check. At least meet people at their need that have been sucked into the Apple culture, by offering an affordable, user customizable mid-sized case, sans superfluous big screen, like the G3s of the late '90s. Will Apple do this? I wouldn't hold my breath.